The Creative Act vs. How to Write One Song
The Creative Act
“I set out to write a book about what to do to make a great work of art. Instead, it revealed itself to be a book on how to be.” —Rick Rubin
How to Write One Song
There are few creative acts more mysterious and magical than writing a song. But what if the goal wasn't so mysterious and was actually achievable for anyone who wants to experience more magic and creativity in their life? That's something that anyone will be inspired to do after reading Jeff Tweedy's How to Write One Song. Why one song? Because the difference between one song and many songs isn't a cute semantic trick—it's an important distinction that can simplify a notoriously confusing art form. The idea of becoming a capital-S songwriter can seem daunting, but approached as a focused, self-contained event, the mystery and fear subsides, and songwriting becomes an exciting pursuit. And then there is the energizing, nourishing creativity that can open up. How to Write One Song brings readers into the intimate process of writing one song—lyrics, music, and putting it all together—and accesses the deep sense of wonder that remains at the heart of this curious, yet incredibly...
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| No pros yet, would you like to add one? | ||
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| No cons yet, would you like to add one? | ||
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| Insightful and practical songwriting tips | 1 | |
| Encourages creativity and self-expression | 1 | |
| Accessible for beginners and experienced musicians | 1 | |
| Engaging and conversational writing style | 1 |
| Item | Votes | Upvote |
|---|---|---|
| May be too basic for some | 1 |
Frequently Asked Questions
'The Creative Act' by Rick Rubin is described as a book on how to be, rather than specific steps to create art. It focuses more on the philosophical aspects of creativity. 'How to Write One Song' by Jeff Tweedy, on the other hand, provides practical songwriting tips and encourages creativity and self-expression in a more hands-on manner, making it more accessible for both beginners and experienced musicians. If you are looking for practical advice and step-by-step guidance in songwriting, 'How to Write One Song' may be better suited for fostering creativity. However, if you are interested in a broader philosophical approach to creativity, 'The Creative Act' might be more beneficial.
'How to Write One Song' by Jeff Tweedy is more suitable for beginners as it provides insightful and practical songwriting tips that are accessible for both beginners and experienced musicians. The book's engaging and conversational writing style makes it easy to follow and encourages creativity and self-expression. 'The Creative Act' by Rick Rubin, while insightful, is more philosophical and may not provide the step-by-step guidance that beginners might be looking for.
'The Creative Act' by Rick Rubin is a book that explores the essence of creativity and being. Initially intended to be a guide on how to create great works of art, it evolved into a broader examination of how to live a creative life. The book delves into the philosophical aspects of creativity, providing insights and reflections on how to harness one's inner creative potential.
Rick Rubin is a renowned music producer and co-founder of Def Jam Recordings. He has worked with a wide array of artists across various genres, including Johnny Cash, Beastie Boys, and Red Hot Chili Peppers. Known for his minimalist production style and profound influence on the music industry, Rubin has also ventured into writing, with 'The Creative Act' being one of his notable works.
'The Creative Act' touches on several key themes, including the nature of creativity, the importance of mindfulness, and the process of artistic expression. Rick Rubin emphasizes the significance of being present and open to inspiration, as well as the value of persistence and authenticity in the creative journey.
As of now, there are no user-generated pros and cons for 'The Creative Act'. However, readers may appreciate its deep philosophical insights and practical advice on creativity. Some may find its abstract nature challenging, depending on their expectations and familiarity with Rubin's style.
'How to Write One Song' by Jeff Tweedy is a guide that demystifies the process of songwriting, making it accessible to anyone. The book emphasizes the importance of focusing on writing just one song, which can simplify the creative process and reduce the intimidation often associated with songwriting. It covers the entire process from lyrics to music composition, and aims to integrate creativity into daily life, offering hope, inspiration, and joy to those who engage with it.
Pros of 'How to Write One Song' include insightful and practical songwriting tips, encouragement of creativity and self-expression, accessibility for both beginners and experienced musicians, and an engaging, conversational writing style. One con is that the book may be too basic for some readers who are looking for more advanced techniques.
