Amazon Cognito vs. Clerk
Amazon Cognito
aws.amazon.com/pm/cognito/The biggest advantage of Cognito is that it's a part of the AWS ecosystem and integrates well with other AWS services. The free tier comes with 50,000 MAUs and the price for each additional MAU starts at $0.0055/month and goes down to as low as $0.0025/month as you scale to tens of millions of users. It integrated with four federated identity providers - your users can sign up with Facebook, Google, Apple and Amazon.
Clerk
clerk.com/Clerk is a comprehensive authentication and user management platform. It comes with embeddable UIs, APIs and admin dashboards for user management. Clerk offers official SDKs for Next.js, React, JavaScript, Node.js, Remix, Go, Gatsby, and Ruby / Rails. There are many more community SDKs for other frameworks and languages. They have a free tier of 10,000 MAUs and a $25/month Pro tier with $0.02/MAU. Enhanced authentication, with SMS auth, device tracking and revocation, simultaneous sessions and SAML authentication costs additional $100/month. Admin add-on, with user impersonation and enhanced roles is another $100/month.
Pros
- Generous free tier× 1
- Low price per monthly active user× 1
- Part of AWS ecosystem× 1
Cons
- Confusing, sometimes misleading documentation× 1
- Difficult to set up× 1
Pros
Cons
Frequently Asked Questions
Amazon Cognito and Clerk both offer robust authentication solutions but cater to different needs. Amazon Cognito integrates seamlessly with other AWS services, which can be a significant advantage if you're already using the AWS ecosystem. It also offers a generous free tier and a low price per monthly active user as you scale. However, it has been criticized for confusing and sometimes misleading documentation and can be difficult to set up. On the other hand, Clerk provides comprehensive authentication and user management features with official SDKs for multiple frameworks. Clerk's pricing includes a free tier of 10,000 MAUs and a Pro tier at $25/month with additional costs for enhanced authentication and admin add-ons. Clerk might be a better choice if you need specific SDKs and ease of use but could become more expensive with added features.
The pros of Amazon Cognito include its generous free tier, low price per monthly active user, and seamless integration with the AWS ecosystem. However, users have reported that the documentation can be confusing and sometimes misleading, and setting up the service can be difficult.
Amazon Cognito is a user authentication service that is part of the AWS ecosystem. It allows users to sign up and sign in with federated identity providers like Facebook, Google, Apple, and Amazon. The service offers a free tier with 50,000 monthly active users (MAUs), and the cost for additional users starts at $0.0055 per MAU, decreasing as the number of users increases.
The main features of Amazon Cognito include integration with four federated identity providers (Facebook, Google, Apple, and Amazon), a generous free tier with 50,000 monthly active users, and competitive pricing that decreases as the number of users scales. It also integrates well with other AWS services, making it a comprehensive solution for user authentication within the AWS ecosystem.
Clerk is a comprehensive authentication and user management platform that provides embeddable UIs, APIs, and admin dashboards for user management. It supports multiple frameworks and languages through official and community SDKs.
Clerk offers embeddable UIs, APIs, and admin dashboards for user management. It provides official SDKs for Next.js, React, JavaScript, Node.js, Remix, Go, Gatsby, and Ruby/Rails, along with community SDKs for other frameworks and languages. Clerk also includes features such as SMS authentication, device tracking and revocation, simultaneous sessions, and SAML authentication.
Clerk has a free tier that supports up to 10,000 Monthly Active Users (MAUs). The Pro tier costs $25 per month with an additional charge of $0.02 per MAU. Enhanced authentication features and an admin add-on each cost an additional $100 per month.
Clerk supports a variety of frameworks and languages through official SDKs, including Next.js, React, JavaScript, Node.js, Remix, Go, Gatsby, and Ruby/Rails. There are also many community SDKs available for other frameworks and languages.
Enhanced authentication features in Clerk, which include SMS authentication, device tracking and revocation, simultaneous sessions, and SAML authentication, cost an additional $100 per month.
The admin add-on for Clerk includes features such as user impersonation and enhanced roles. This add-on costs an additional $100 per month.
