Amazon Cognito vs. Keycloak
Amazon Cognito
The biggest advantage of Cognito is that it's a part of the AWS ecosystem and integrates well with other AWS services. The free tier comes with 50,000 MAUs and the price for each additional MAU starts at $0.0055/month and goes down to as low as $0.0025/month as you scale to tens of millions of users. It integrated with four federated identity providers - your users can sign up with Facebook, Google, Apple and Amazon.
Keycloak
Keycloak is an open source identity and access management solution. It supports Keycloak single-sign-on and OpenID Connect or SAML 2.0 Identity Providers (Google, Facebook, GitHub etc).
Reviews
Reviews
Item | Votes | Upvote |
---|---|---|
Generous free tier | 1 | |
Low price per monthly active user | 1 | |
Part of AWS ecosystem | 1 |
Item | Votes | Upvote |
---|---|---|
Confusing, sometimes misleading documentation | 1 | |
Difficult to set up | 1 |
Item | Votes | Upvote |
---|---|---|
No pros yet, would you like to add one? |
Item | Votes | Upvote |
---|---|---|
No cons yet, would you like to add one? |
Frequently Asked Questions
Amazon Cognito is better integrated with the AWS ecosystem, making it a great choice if you are already using AWS services. It offers a generous free tier and a low price per monthly active user, making it cost-effective as you scale. However, its documentation can be confusing and it can be difficult to set up. Keycloak, on the other hand, is an open-source solution that supports various identity providers like Google, Facebook, and GitHub. It may be more suitable if you prefer an open-source approach and need flexibility in identity provider integration.
Amazon Cognito offers a generous free tier with 50,000 monthly active users (MAUs) and a low price for additional users, making it cost-effective as you scale. The cost per additional MAU starts at $0.0055/month and can go down to $0.0025/month for tens of millions of users. Keycloak is open-source and free to use, but the total cost of ownership will depend on the infrastructure and maintenance costs. If you are already using AWS services, Cognito may be more cost-effective due to its seamless integration.
Amazon Cognito can be difficult to set up and its documentation can sometimes be confusing and misleading. Keycloak, being an open-source solution, may require more initial setup and configuration, but its community and extensive documentation can help mitigate this. The ease of setup will largely depend on your familiarity with the respective platforms and your specific requirements.
The pros of Amazon Cognito include its generous free tier, low price per monthly active user, and seamless integration with the AWS ecosystem. However, users have reported that the documentation can be confusing and sometimes misleading, and setting up the service can be difficult.
Amazon Cognito is a user authentication service that is part of the AWS ecosystem. It allows users to sign up and sign in with federated identity providers like Facebook, Google, Apple, and Amazon. The service offers a free tier with 50,000 monthly active users (MAUs), and the cost for additional users starts at $0.0055 per MAU, decreasing as the number of users increases.
The main features of Amazon Cognito include integration with four federated identity providers (Facebook, Google, Apple, and Amazon), a generous free tier with 50,000 monthly active users, and competitive pricing that decreases as the number of users scales. It also integrates well with other AWS services, making it a comprehensive solution for user authentication within the AWS ecosystem.
Keycloak is an open source identity and access management solution. It supports single-sign-on and integrates with OpenID Connect or SAML 2.0 Identity Providers such as Google, Facebook, and GitHub.
Keycloak offers several features including single-sign-on, identity brokering and social login, user federation, client adapters, and an admin console. It supports standard protocols like OpenID Connect and SAML 2.0.
Currently, there are no user-generated pros and cons for Keycloak. However, some general pros include its open source nature and extensive protocol support. Potential cons may include a steep learning curve for new users.
Organizations that require robust identity and access management solutions can benefit from Keycloak. It is particularly useful for companies needing to implement single-sign-on across multiple applications.
Related Content & Alternatives
- 12.Firebase
Google's Firebase is an entire app development platform that's packed with features.It comes with storage, cloud functions, monitoring and, of course, user authentication. The free tier comes with 50,000 MAUs. Beyond that pricing start at $0.0055/MAU and goes down to as low as $0.0025/MAU as you scale to millions of users. Firebase authentication supports email and password auth, phone auth, magic links, two-factor authentication and social identity providers - mainly Google, Google Play Games, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, Twitter, GitHub and OAuth access tokens.
- 13.Auth0 by Okta
Auth0 is an identity and access management (IAM) platform designed to simplify authentication and authorization for applications. It provides a flexible solution that allows developers to implement secure login systems without having to build them from the ground up. Auth0 supports various authentication methods, including username-password credentials, social logins (like Google, Facebook, and GitHub), enterprise identity providers (such as Active Directory and SAML-based systems), and passwordless options. The platform is highly adaptable, offering over 30 software development kits (SDKs) that cater to a wide range of languages and frameworksβJavaScript, Python, .NET, iOS, Android, and more. This makes integration straightforward regardless of the tech stack. Beyond basic authentication, Auth0 offers advanced features like multi-factor authentication (MFA), single sign-on (SSO), and fine-grained authorization. These tools enable organizations to enforce complex access control policies, supporting both role-based (RBAC) and attribute-based (ABAC) models. Auth0 also addresses enterprise needs through features like user provisioning, directory synchronization, and support for B2B, B2C, and B2E use cases. Itβs designed with scalability in mind, making it suitable for both startups and large enterprises. The platformβs extensibility allows developers to customize authentication flows, implement rules for conditional access, and integrate third-party services. Since its acquisition by Okta, Auth0 operates as a product unit under the Okta umbrella, complementing Oktaβs broader suite of identity solutions while maintaining a developer-first focus. This combination brings together Oktaβs enterprise-grade security with Auth0βs developer-centric approach, offering a comprehensive solution for modern identity challenges.
- 14.Clerk
Clerk is a comprehensive user management and authentication platform designed to streamline how developers handle user accounts within web and mobile applications. It offers a suite of embeddable UI componentsβsuch as <SignIn/>, <SignUp/>, <UserButton/>, and <UserProfile/>βthat integrate seamlessly into your application without redirecting users off-site. These components are fully customizable to match your brand, making the user experience cohesive and frictionless. Under the hood, Clerk provides a robust API and SDKs compatible with modern frameworks like Next.js, Remix, React, and Expo. It handles the entire authentication lifecycle, supporting multifactor authentication (MFA), session management, passwordless sign-in (via magic links or one-time passcodes), and traditional password-based methods with breach detection. The platform also integrates social sign-on (SSO) with over 20 providers, enabling quick user onboarding while adhering to security best practices. Clerkβs security posture includes SOC 2 Type 2 certification and CCPA compliance, with continuous third-party audits and penetration testing. Fraud prevention measures, like disposable email blocking and bot detection powered by machine learning, are built-in to reduce spam and abusive sign-ups. For B2B SaaS applications, Clerk provides advanced multi-tenancy features, enabling organization-based user management with custom roles, permissions, auto-join functionality based on email domains, and invitation systemsβall accessible through both code and an admin dashboard. Developers benefit from rapid integration, significantly reducing the time spent on building authentication systems from scratch. Clerk acts as the single source of truth for user data and integrates seamlessly with popular backend services like Supabase, Firebase, and Convex. With free access for up to 10,000 monthly active users, itβs positioned as a scalable solution that grows with your applicationβs needs.
- 15.Supabase
Supabase is the open-source alternative to Firebase. Like Firebase, it's a complete app development platform with user authentication, cloud functions, APIs, Postgres database, storage, vector embeddings, and other features. Supabase projects come with PostgreSQL's policy engine for fine-grained user access rules. It has social login integrations with Google, Facebook, GitHub, Azure (Microsoft), Gitlab, Twitter, Discord, and many more. They offer a customizable authentication component for React. Phone login and MFA can be added through third-party SMS providers such as Twilio or Bird. The free tier comes with 50,000 monthly active users. The Pro plan, at $25/month, comes with 100,000 MAUs and $0.00325/MAU beyond that.
- 06.Stytch
Stytch provides a suite of tools designed to simplify authentication, authorization, and security for web and mobile applications. If you're developing an app and need a way for users to log inβwhether with passwords, passkeys, or entirely passwordless methodsβStytch offers APIs and SDKs that handle these complexities. Their focus is on making authentication seamless for both developers and end-users while ensuring high security standards. For businesses, particularly B2B SaaS companies, Stytch enables advanced features like multi-tenancy, role-based access control (RBAC), and single sign-on (SSO). They provide an embeddable admin portal, allowing enterprise customers to manage their own authentication configurations, organizational settings, and integrations with identity providersβwithout constant developer involvement. Stytch places a strong emphasis on scalability and flexibility. Their tools are designed to βjust workβ across a range of use cases, from simple consumer apps to complex enterprise platforms. Developers can choose how much of the authentication flow they want to controlβusing pre-built UI components for quick implementation or leveraging headless SDKs and backend APIs for a fully customized experience. Security and fraud prevention are also core to Stytchβs offering. They provide real-time bot detection, device-aware multi-factor authentication, and intelligent rate limiting to protect against credential stuffing and other forms of account abuse. Their infrastructure ensures that login codes and authentication requests are delivered reliably, even when SMS or email providers fail. Stytch supports a broad range of programming languages and frameworks, including Python, Node.js, Java, React, and iOS, making integration into existing tech stacks straightforward. Their platform is designed for developers who want to build secure, user-friendly authentication systems without reinventing the wheel.
- 07.Kinde
Kinde has a generous free plan with up to 10,500 MAU free of charge. Their Pro plan costs $25/month and the price for each additional MAU over 10,500 is $0.0175.
- 08.Ory
Ory is an API-first identity manager. They offer authentication, analytics, access control, machine-to-machine authentication and more. They have SDKs for the major languages: - Dart - .NET - Elixir - Go - Java - JavaScript - PHP - Python - Ruby - Rust Unfortunately, they don't offer a free tier. Pricing starts at $29/month and includes 1,000 daily active users. Then it's $30 / 1,000 additional DAUs.
- 09.Appwrite
Appwrite is an open-source platform for building scalable applications. It comes with authentication, databases, storage, and functions. It's basically a complete development platform. They have an extremely generous free plan with 75,000 MAUs free of charge and their Pro plan is only $15/month. Appwrite offers email and password login, phone auth, magic links, email OTP, anonymous login, JWT login, SSR login, custom tokens, and two-factor authentication.
- 010.Auth.js
Formerly known as NextAuth. It's is an open-source authentication library originally built for NextJS. Auth.js is free to use and comes with over 80 integrations for various third-party identity providers such as Google, Facebook, Auth0, Apple etc. You can use it with your own database if you choose to. It works with MySQL, Postgres, MSSQL and MongoDB. Auth.js is compatible with Next.js, SvelteKit and SolidStart as of March 2024.
- 012.Gluu Server
Gluu offers various authentication solutions based on open-source software. There is a self-hosted solution, a managed solution, and a free fully open-source solution based on the Linux Foundation Janssen Project.
- 013.Okta
Okta is an identity provider for organizations. It offers enterprise solutions for managing workforce and employee identities. It's HIPAA BAA and PCI compliant.
- 014.Lucia Auth
Lucia is an open source auth library that abstracts away the complexity of handling sessions. It works with any JS runtime - Node.js, Bun, Deno, Cloudflare Workers. It's also fully typed. It integrates with MongoDB. PostgreSQL, MySQL, SQLite, and with their respective ORMs and query builders.
- 015.GoPasswordless
GoPasswordless is an authentication service and SDK that focuses on enabling passwordless authentication flows in web apps.
- 016.OTPLESS
Authenticate customers with WhatsApp, SMS, Email, Biometrics, and more, with a 98% conversion rate on signup and sign-in.
- 03.Creduse
Instant credit system integration for Apps and Games with Creduse API. Simplify credit management for your application or game with our developer-friendly API solution. Enjoy quick integration, robust scalability, and comprehensive support, plus powerful analytics to monitor user activity.
- 021.PostPuma
PostPuma is a social media management platform powered by AI, designed to streamline and enhance how businesses maintain their online presence. From effortlessly scheduling posts to delivering AI-driven recommendations that optimize content and analyze performance, PostPuma equips users with the tools they need to manage social media effectively and efficiently. Ideal for small to medium-sized businesses, marketing teams, and content creators, itβs a solution tailored to save time, boost organization, and grow audiences. The platformβs standout features include a centralized content scheduler that lets users plan posts across multiple social media platforms from one intuitive dashboard. AI-driven content optimization offers tailored suggestions to refine tone, style, and content ideas for maximum audience appeal. Meanwhile, performance analytics provide actionable insights into audience behavior, enabling users to fine-tune strategies for better results. For teams, PostPuma supports smooth collaboration with role assignments and built-in approval workflows. Additionally, multi-platform integration ensures every account is seamlessly managed in one place. The benefits of PostPuma are clear: automate time-consuming tasks, maintain consistent posting schedules to enhance engagement, and make data-driven decisions with easy-to-read analytics. The platformβs user-friendly design ensures accessibility for beginners while offering advanced tools for experienced marketers. Teams especially benefit from streamlined collaboration, avoiding the confusion of disjointed workflows. Getting started is straightforwardβconnect your social media accounts to PostPuma, and the platformβs AI tools take it from there. You can generate or refine posts, schedule them to align with peak engagement times, and monitor their performance using the analytics dashboard. Teams can collaborate effortlessly, ensuring a unified approach to content creation and publishing.
- 024.Adligator
Adligator is more than just an ad aggregator; itβs a sophisticated AI tool designed to give businesses, marketers and affiliate marketologists a strategic advantage in the highly competitive world of online advertising. By aggregating ads from major platforms like Facebook, Instagram, Facebook Messenger, and the Audience Network, Adligator enables users to dissect and understand their competitors' marketing strategies. This service provides a granular view into ad placements, formats, audience targeting, and performance metrics, empowering businesses to craft data-driven advertising strategies that drive results.
- 032.AIChief
AIChief is the largest and fastest digital platform providing valuable insights into AI tools, their reviews, potential guides, personal opinions, insightful journals, and daily updates about the latest AI trends and usage. Our easy-to-understand guides intertwine artificial intelligence with humans and make it easier to understand how AI is transforming the ways of our lives.
- 022.Your eCom Agent
Your eCom Agent is an AI-powered toolset designed to save Amazon sellers time and improve their business with quick, actionable insights. Analyze competitors, optimize listings, and streamline your workflow in minutes. Try it free with a 7-day trial. Key Features: - Product Development: Analyze competitors to identify key features and solutions to customer issues. - Review Analyzer: Summarize any ASIN's reviews into Pros, Cons, and insights. - Bundle & Add-On Ideas: Generate ideas to enhance your product offerings. - Brand Developer: Create a unique brand identity. - Product Ideation: Discover new product ideas. - Listing Fixer: Get personalized recommendations to optimize your listings. Benefits: - Automated Workflows: Efficiently manage tasks with AI-powered automation. - Creative Solutions: Find opportunities you may have overlooked. - Save Time: Complete tasks in minutes, saving you hours. How It Works: For all the tools all you need to do is provide product ASINs and optional additional text and click run. The AI will automatically do the rest of the work for you.